In a week of extraordinary drama at Fox News, two of the network’s most prominent female voices—Emily Compagno and Jessica Tarlov—were reportedly escorted off set following two separate explosive clashes during live broadcasts. These unprecedented incidents have thrown The Five, one of Fox News’ most-watched programs, into chaos and ignited a storm of speculation about the internal dynamics behind the scenes.

As viewers reel from the unfolding chaos, Fox News remains tight-lipped, issuing no official statement. Meanwhile, industry insiders suggest that tensions at the network have been simmering for months—and may now be boiling over.

Compagno’s Confrontation: “Enough Is Enough”

Emily Compagno, a former criminal defense attorney and co-host known for her firm stances and measured demeanor, shocked producers and viewers when she stormed off the set mid-broadcast. Sources close to the situation say Compagno grew visibly agitated during a discussion on the 2024 immigration bill. When her remarks were repeatedly interrupted by another panelist (unnamed by insiders), she snapped.

“If you want to host the show, go ahead,” she reportedly said off-mic before tossing her notes and removing her microphone.

Producers rushed to cut to a commercial, and Compagno was quietly escorted off set moments later. Her sudden exit sent Twitter (now X) into a frenzy, with hashtags like #EmilyWalksOut and #FoxMeltdown trending nationwide.

Jessica Tarlov vs. Jeanine Pirro: The Blowup No One Saw Coming

Just one day later, an even more volatile clash erupted—this time between liberal voice Jessica Tarlov and conservative firebrand Jeanine Pirro. What began as a spirited exchange about election interference quickly turned personal.

Tarlov accused Pirro of dominating the conversation and shouted, “You don’t get to shout me down every time I speak!”

Pirro fired back with characteristic force: “Maybe if you made a point worth listening to, we wouldn’t have to!”

When the shouting match reached its peak, Tarlov stood up, ripped out her earpiece, and yelled off-camera, “Cut the mic—this is gaslighting!” before storming off the set. Producers were again forced to go to commercial, and when the show returned, Tarlov was gone.

Behind the Scenes: A Pattern of Boiling Tensions

According to multiple sources within the network, these incidents didn’t come out of nowhere.

“There’s been friction for months,” one production assistant told Media Pulse. “You’ve got strong personalities, differing ideologies, and mounting pressure. It was only a matter of time before something gave.”

Another insider added that Tarlov had privately complained about being “boxed in” and constantly dismissed during serious policy conversations. Meanwhile, Compagno, usually composed and respectful, was said to be increasingly frustrated with the show’s combative tone and lack of structured debate.

Fan Reactions: Praise, Outrage, and Deep Division

The reactions from fans and media personalities alike have been intense—and divided.

Pro-Tarlov users defended her decision to walk off, calling her treatment on the show unfair and labeling Pirro’s conduct as “rude” and “bullying.” Hashtags like #StandWithJessica and #LetHerSpeak flooded social feeds.

Meanwhile, Team Pirro supporters argued that Tarlov was unable to handle tough debate and called for her removal. Some conservative fans even suggested The Five should eliminate liberal voices altogether.

“Jessica brought this on herself,” wrote one commenter.
“We’re here for tough debates—not tantrums,” posted another.

What’s Next for Emily and Jessica?

As of this writing, Emily Compagno has not returned to The Five, and no official announcement has been made about a suspension or leave. Some insiders believe her walk-off was a one-time loss of composure, and she’s expected to return in the coming days.

However, Jessica Tarlov’s situation is more complex. Sources say Fox News executives are deeply divided on how to handle her outburst. Some argue she should be given time off to cool tensions; others believe the incident has crossed a line, and she may face disciplinary action—or even an exit.

A Network Under Pressure

These twin meltdowns have come at a particularly precarious time for Fox News. As the 2024 election cycle heats up, the network is under intense scrutiny—and pressure to maintain its ratings dominance. Internal tensions have reportedly increased as the show attempts to strike a balance between entertaining debate and serious journalism.

Several staffers have anonymously voiced concerns about The Five’s format, claiming that the show’s current structure encourages conflict rather than clarity.

“It’s not about informing viewers anymore,” one producer said. “It’s about who can out-shout the other person before the segment ends.”

Could These Moments Signal the Beginning of a Format Shake-Up?

Longtime media watchers say the chaos may be more than temporary—it may indicate a larger shift coming for the show and the network.

“What we’re witnessing might be The Five’s tipping point,” said veteran media analyst Jenna Clarke. “Audiences want fiery discussion, but not if it looks like personal attacks or unprofessional conduct. If this becomes the norm, they risk losing credibility.”

Final Thoughts: A Daytime Powerhouse at a Crossroads

The Five has long been a ratings juggernaut for Fox News, but these recent incidents raise serious questions about the network’s ability to manage its own talent and live programming.

Whether Emily Compagno and Jessica Tarlov return or not, one thing is clear: the show can no longer afford to ignore the growing tension among its cast—or the expectations of its viewers.

As the network scrambles to contain the fallout, many are left wondering:

Will The Five evolve into a more moderated, balanced panel?

Or will it double down on the fiery clashes that drive ratings—but also risk alienating the audience?

Stay tuned—because Fox News may be entering its most volatile era yet.